This is a pretty fun exercise, and I hope lots of people participate. I went with an outfielder for my fake player and took a bunch of traits from the mid 90s on.
Speed - Jacoby. He was just so damn fast.
Arm - Cespedes. He was only here a short time, and isn't the best fielders, but his arm is insane.
Fielding and first step - JBJ. He really is one of the best fielders I've ever seen, and he does it without blazing speed.
Base running - Rickey Henderson...Jacoby was great, but how can you go against the best ever?
Durability - Xander...hopefully this isn't a jinx.
Vision - Manny.
Hit tool - Nomar. This is kind of a cop out to put both vision and hit tool on here, but these two guys have to both be taken into consideration.
Power - Papi. Could have been Vaughn or one of the randoms like Willie Mo Pena.
And of course, you can't talk about clutch hitting without the name David Ortiz.