This is a follow up to the Top-10 Clearinghouse and includes the full rankings of various sites: Missing are Hardball Times and Baseball Prospectus which tend to come out later. The first table has the raw list data. I then took the players and averaged their rankings to come up with a cummulative ranking for the Top 20. If a player did not appear on a list say for BA's Top 10 then they were ranked 11th and so forth. Tables after the jump
Top Prospect Rankings
RK | BA | FG | SP | MLB | BB: R | BB:S | MLBD |
1 | Middlebrooks | Bogaerts | Middlebrooks | Bogaerts | Barnes | Bogaerts | Bogaerts |
2 | Bogaerts | Middlebrooks | Ranaudo | Barnes | Bogaerts | Barnes | Barnes |
3 | Swihart | Cecchini | Bogaerts | Middlebrooks | Middlebrooks | Cecchini | Middlebrooks |
4 | Ranaudo | Swihart | Iglesias | Lavarnway | Swihart | Middlebrooks | Lavarnway |
5 | Brentz | Barnes | Lavarnway | Cecchini | Cecchini | Swihart | Cecchini |
6 | Jacobs | Ranaudo | Kalish# | Jacobs | Lavarnway | Ranaudo | Ranaudo |
7 | Cecchini | Bradley | Barnes | Swihart | Bradley | Lavarnway | Swihart |
8 | Barnes | Lavarnway | Brentz | Coyle | Brentz | Owens | Brentz |
9 | Lavarnway | Owens | Jacobs | Brentz | Owens | Brentz | Jacobs |
10 | Bradley | Jacobs | Swihart | Ranaudo | Jacobs | Bradley | Owens |
11 | Iglesias | Coyle | Owens | Iglesias | Iglesias | Iglesias | |
12 | Brentz | Cecchini | Iglesias | Ranaudo | Jacobs | Coyle | |
13 | Vitek | Doubront | Bradley | Coyle | Doubront | Bradley | |
14 | Tazawa | Wilson | Wilson | Britton | Coyle | Britton | |
15 | Head* | Britton | Workman | Alcantara* | Workman | Workman | |
16 | Vitek | Weiland* | Weiland* | ||||
17 | Pimentel | Doubront | |||||
18 | Tejeda | Pimentel | |||||
19 | Bradley | Vazquez | |||||
20 | Owens | Vitek |
KEY: BA (Baseball America), FG (Fangraphs), SP (soxprospects), MLB (Minor League Ball), BB:R (Bullpen Banter, Jeff Reese), BB:S (Bullpen Banter: Al Skorupa), MLBD (MLB Dirt)
* Player has since been traded ans was not cummulatively ranked
# Kalish only appears on soxprospects due to his Major League at bats and thus was not cummulatively ranked
Cummulative Rankings
Player | SC | CRK |
Bogaerts | 1.57 | 1 |
Middlebrooks | 2.43 | 2 |
Barnes | 3.86 | 3 |
Swihart | 5.71 | 4 |
Cecchini | 5.71 | 5 |
Lavarnway | 6.14 | 6 |
Ranaudo | 6.57 | 7 |
Brentz | 8.43 | 8 |
Jacobs | 8.86 | 9 |
Iglesias | 10.14 | 10 |
Owens | 11.14 | 11 |
Bradley | 11.29 | 12 |
Coyle | 12.14 | 13 |
Doubront | 14.71 | 14 |
Britton | 15.29 | 15 |
Vitek | 15.57 | 16T |
Workman | 15.57 | 16T |
Pimentel | 15.85 | 18 |
Tejeda | 16.43 | 19 |
Tazawa | 16.57 | 20T |
Vazquez | 16.57 | 20T |