Miller, Iglasius, and Kalish or Reddick?
I would do that deal.
Miller has at least a chance to be a decent No. 4 starter, if he can get over being a head case. Iglasius is a good fielding SS to give Mets depth. Reddick or Kalish gives depth behind Beltran, who may leave the Mets soon.
I worry about Reyes health, but we need to win now, not in 5 years.
The proverb that I live by is never trade a horse for two ponies. By that standard, the Mets should not do the deal. But any of the 3 prospects could turn out to be solid. Even all 3 could be solid.